Resource Center

Is Overtime Pay Taxed More? All You Need To Know

Avoid tax headaches & uncover hidden overtime costs.
min to read
min video

Overtime's true cost is often hidden.

Timeero brings it into clear focus.

Schedule a free consultation today

As a business owner, requiring or working overtime can be necessary to meet deadlines or handle unexpected demands. 

Although overtime can be beneficial in the long run, it is known to bring payroll complexities. Inaccurate overtime details—calculations, compliance, taxes—can expose your business to legal risks and cause conflict with employees.

Understanding how overtime impacts tax calculations is critical to running a smooth business. The right tools can help you streamline your payroll process and remain compliant with tax reporting standards.

Please Note: This article provides general information and is not intended as tax advice. Consult a tax professional for guidance specific to your situation.

Is Overtime Pay Taxed More? Getting to the Bottom of the Myth

Let's debunk a common myth: overtime is not taxed at a higher rate. The IRS treats overtime the same as regular pay. 

However, when employees earn overtime, their total income might push them into a higher tax bracket, slightly increasing their overall tax liability. 

Tax liability refers to the total amount of tax an individual or business is obligated to pay to the government. When an employee's income increases, their tax liability also increases, which means they may owe more taxes at the end of the year.

Now that we've cleared up this misconception let's examine how overtime can still indirectly impact your tax situation.

Understanding Tax Brackets

Imagine the tax system as a series of steps on a ladder. Each step, called a tax bracket, represents a range of income. 

The higher the wage bracket, the higher the tax rate applied to that income. When overtime increases an employee's annual income, they might sit in a higher tax bracket.

How Overtime Changes Things

When employees earn overtime, their total income increases, which could land them on a higher rung of the tax ladder. 

But remember, only the income that falls within this new bracket gets taxed at the higher rate. Any income that stays in their regular bracket stays taxed the same.

Example: Navigating the Tax Brackets

Suppose an employee in Texas earns $50,000 this year in regular wages. Overtime pushes their total income to $56,000. 

As a result, their total income falls into two separate income tax brackets. With the 2024 tax brackets, this means:

  • The first $47,150 of their income is still taxed at 12%. (the lower bracket they were in originally)
  • The income earned between $47,150 and $56,000 ($11,275) is taxed at the higher rate of 22%. ( overtime income landed the remaining balance in the next tax bracket)

Many people wrongly think ALL of their income is taxed at the highest rate when they get a bump from overtime. The $50,000 earned from regular wages does NOT suddenly get taxed at 22%. Only the additional income in the new bracket faces the higher rate.

Payroll Withholding: Your Role in Accuracy

While employees are ultimately responsible for the accuracy of their income taxes, as a business owner, you play a role in ensuring the correct amount of taxes are withheld from each paycheck. 

Overtime significantly impacts an employee's total income, directly affecting how much tax should be withheld. Your understanding of tax laws and accurate payroll management is essential to ensure you use the correct withholding tables.

If working overtime pushes an employee into a new bracket, these additional earnings may need to be withheld at a higher rate. 

How Overtime Impacts Withholding: A Calculation Example

While overtime itself isn't taxed differently, it does change your employee's total earnings. Let's break down an example to understand how overtime impacts tax withholding.  

Alice is a full-time home healthcare worker.  She is paid at a rate of $20 per hour and typically works 40 hours per week.  One week, a patient needed additional care so she worked 5 hours of overtime.  

1. Calculate Total Taxable Income 

  • $20.00 per hour x 40 hours per week = $800 regular earnings
  • 5 hours of overtime x $30.00 per hour (time-and-a-half) = $150 overtime pay
  • Total income: $800 + $150 = $950.00

2. Find the Tax Bracket

 IRS Publication 15-T provides federal income tax withholding tables. You'll determine the correct amount to withhold based on Alice's filing status (single filer, with no dependents) and her $950 income.

3. Accuracy Makes a Difference

Under-withholding means Alice might get extra money, but she will owe money at tax time. Over-withholding gives her a larger refund but reduces her weekly take-home pay.

While you'll still need to use IRS resources for calculations, tools like Timeero provide you with a precise report of overtime hours worked when the pay period arrives.

Beyond Federal: Understanding Your State's Overtime Rules

Up to this point we've focused on how overtime indirectly affects federal payroll taxes.  It's important to note that overtime has an even more direct impact on labor costs due to stricter state laws. 

The FLSA sets minimum wage and overtime pay rates.  Overtime rates are generally paid at time-and-a-half once an employee exceeds 40 hours worked in a week. 

Individual state rules are layered on top of federal regulations, adding complexity to your payroll calculations and increasing your potential for penalties if those rules are violated. State laws significantly impact things like:

  • When Overtime Kicks In: Some states require overtime pay after 8 hours are worked in a single day, instead of 40 hours weekly.
  • Double-time Requirements: In California, employers may need to pay double the regular hourly rate after 12 hours are worked in a day or for the seventh consecutive workday.
  • Industry-Specific Rules: Overtime rules and exemptions can vary depending on what type of business you operate and where you are located.

While most states adhere to federal minimum requirements, some states have additional regulations regarding overtime pay or exemptions. Knowing state-specific details is necessary to stay compliant and avoid unexpected costs. We've provided numerous resources to help you navigate relevant laws efficiently:

Important: Always consult your state's official labor department website for the latest information.

The Role of Time-Tracking Software: From Compliance to Cost Control

Tracking time with spreadsheets or paper timesheets are a recipe for disaster.  These outdated methods often lead to errors, overpayments, and compliance risks. 

Dedicated time-tracking software like Timeero can help you overcome headaches associated with reporting and control overtime costs. 

Let's explore how Timeero transforms the time-tracking process.

Accuracy is Key

timeero iphone gps time clock
Timeero: GPS Time Clock App

Timeero captures precise clock-in/clock-out times, break durations, and GPS location data. This detailed information eliminates disputes regarding overtime and is particularly valuable when stricter state overtime rules apply (ex: California’s Overtime Law).

timeero employee amd client timesheet
Using the Timeero mobile app, capture employee and client signatures on timesheets.

Employees can verify their timesheets by attaching a digital signature, adding an extra layer of accuracy and transparency.

timeero timesheet with audit log
Timeero’s History Log tracks every change for complete transparency.

Timeero also maintains a comprehensive history log of all timesheet entries. This encourages accountability and provides a clear audit trail if needed.

Streamlined Payroll

timeero integrations
Available Timeero Integrations

Timeero integrates seamlessly with popular payroll software like Gusto, ADP, and QuickBooks. Timeero’s integration capabilities eliminate manual data entry, reduce errors, and simplify calculating complex overtime pay scenarios.

Location Accountability

timeero geofencing restriction
Enforce your worksite presence policy by requiring employees to clock in only when on-site.

Geofencing technology lets you create a virtual perimeter around the job site. Employees are required to be physically present within the work zone to clock in or out, which minimizes potential cases of time theft, specifically 'buddy punching' where coworkers clock each other in.

For more information on the benefits of GPS-enabled time tracking, see our article: Five Best GPS Tracking Apps.

Overtime Prevention Tools 

timeero overtime notifications
Clock-out reminders prevent overtime violations and payroll errors.

Configurable overtime thresholds prevents surprises for both employers and managers, reducing the risk of unexpected costs and compliance issues. Some employees might not even realize they qualify for overtime, so this feature promotes transparency. 

timeero company settings
Control your overtime costs by setting customizable thresholds.

Timeero has the ability to automatically clock employees out after they work a certain number of hours, which is customizable by state.

Timeero Prevents unexpected overtime
Prevent unexpected overtime by enabling the automatic clock-out feature.

Beyond Basic Compliance

Timeero overtime
Add a new payroll overtime rule from the Administrator Dashboard.

By using a tool like Timeero, you demonstrate to employees that you value fair compensation and that you're committed to compliance. 

Timeero makes it easier to stay on the right side of the law. With features like customized overtime rules and the ability to accurately handle 'split shifts' across midnight, Timeero takes the guesswork out of complex situations.

Plus, with overtime data readily accessible, you can analyze trends and see where overtime might be a symptom of understaffing or inefficient processes - turning that data into actionable insights for your business.

Ready to see what Timeero can do for your business? Read our detailed Timeero review.

How Many Hours of Overtime Is Too Much for Taxes?

Technically, there's no "too much" from a purely tax viewpoint. But remember, there are several other costs employers must factor in:

Employer-side Taxes 

Each dollar of overtime pay increases your portion of FICA taxes (Social Security and Medicare). These percentages may seem small, but when overtime is a frequent occurrence, the costs are significant.

Workers' Compensation Premiums

Depending on your industry and insurer, employees working longer hours may be considered a greater risk, leading to higher premiums. Costs can vary based on the specific type of work involved.

The Hidden Costs of Overtime 

  • Employee burnout and turnover. Relying too heavily on overtime makes employees less productive, error-prone, and likely to quit, which increases the costs of hiring and training replacements.
  • Decreased morale. Excessive overtime negatively impacts workplace culture, especially if it feels mandatory or isn't distributed fairly. Disengaged employees cost businesses significantly in lost productivity.
  • Legal Risks. Miscalculating overtime (even accidentally) or violating state-specific rules can result in fines, penalties, and even employee lawsuits.

The Strategic Mindset on Overtime: When Is It Worthwhile?

While overtime can be a necessary short-term fix to handle workload demands, strategic decision-making requires looking beyond the immediate gain and considering long-term costs. 

Let's break down a simplified scenario to illustrate these costs.

Scenario: The Overtime Trap

Your warehouse staff is paid at a rate of $20.00 per hour.  They regularly work an additional 5 hours of overtime weekly. Paid at  time-and-a-half, that's an additional $150 per employee each week. But the costs are just beginning.  Now you must take into account: 

  • Hidden Taxes: Add your company's 7.65% share of FICA taxes (Social Security and Medicare).
  • Increased Risk: Longer hours increase the likelihood of accidents and injuries, potentially increasing workers' compensation premiums.
  • Productivity Loss: Employee fatigue lowers production output and increases error rate. Exhausted employees cost you more in the long run.

The Hiring Alternative

Requiring employees to work overtime hours results in additional costs that impact your net profit. Could hiring a part-time employee (20 hours/week) eliminate costly overtime hours? 

Before going this route, here are a few things you should consider:

Total Wage Cost. Calculate their hourly rate plus minimal benefits.

Upfront Investment. Factor in hiring and training costs that are spread over a realistic retention period (e.g., six months).

Beyond the Numbers. A new hire may bring flexibility. An additional employee may help cover vacations, sick days, and provide extra help during peak seasons.  Having enough staff reduces  the need for requiring unplanned overtime.

PRO TIP: There is a time and place for overtime, such as when short-term demands must be met.  The goal is to make educated choices, not avoid overtime entirely.

Overtime Policy Best Practices: Protecting Your Business and Employees

Up to this point, you've analyzed the true costs of overtime work which include tax withholding rates and hidden impacts.

But relying solely on analysis will not prevent issues associated with overtime such as unexpected costs, legal trouble, and a demoralized workforce. To mitigate these issues, you need a tool that turns insight into action . A well-crafted overtime policy puts you in control, protecting your business and workforce. 

Let's outline the essential components of an overtime policy that achieves compliance and creates a fair, transparent workplace.

1. Eligibility: Define Who Qualifies for Overtime

Start by explaining the basic requirements of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), which distinguishes between exempt and nonexempt employees.

Then, list which job titles or classifications within your company are eligible for overtime wages. This prevents confusion and potential disputes.

If your state has additional eligibility rules (e.g., some states have overtime rules specific to farmworkers), mention these here.

2. Authorization: The Importance of Pre-Approval

Emphasize that the employee's manager or supervisor must pre-approve all extra hours that will be worked to prevent surprise costs. 

If rare circumstances arise where post-overtime approval for working off the clock is acceptable, define these circumstances very clearly. 

Outline potential consequences for employees who work unauthorized overtime.

3. Pay Calculation: Transparency is Key

Clearly state your company's overtime pay rate and whether it aligns with or exceeds the federal minimum. 

Highlight any state rules that impact calculation methods, like daily overtime thresholds in California. 

Also, specify when your company's workweek begins and ends, as this impacts overtime calculations.

4. Communication and Review

Distributing your written overtime policy through a company handbook, intranet, or other internal channels ensures all employees are informed. 

Regularly review and update your policy, especially when federal, state, or company regulations change.

Additional Considerations

Some industries or states allow 'comp time' (time off) instead of overtime pay. If this applies to your business, your overtime policy must address this with absolute clarity. Ambiguity about compensatory time can lead to serious legal issues.

Also, consider having employees sign a form confirming they've read and fully understand the overtime policy. This documentation promotes accountability and helps protect your business.

Tracking Overtime and Enforcing Your Overtime Policy: Where Timeero Shines

A well-crafted overtime policy is only effective if it is paired with precise time tracking. Outdated methods like manual timesheets create risks – errors, disputes, and even the potential for manipulation. 

Timeero eliminates these problems, ensuring your policy is consistently and fairly enforced.

With Timeero, you gain:

  • Accuracy: Unquestionable records of clock-in/out times, breaks, and location data.
  • Compliance: Confidence that overtime calculations are correct, even with complex state laws, minimizing legal risks.
  • Cost Control: Overtime alerts and reporting tools let you pinpoint unsustainable patterns before they damage your bottom line.
  • Employee Trust: Transparency around hours worked promotes a fair and accountable workplace.

FAQ: Understanding Overtime & Taxes

What is the tax rate on overtime earnings? 

Overtime is taxed at the same rate as regular pay.

How is overtime taxed?

While overtime isn't taxed differently, overtime earnings can push you into a higher tax bracket. Only the income within the higher bracket is taxed at the higher rate.

Is overtime taxed more in California? 

Although California's strict overtime rules can increase costs, tax rates still follow federal guidelines.

Tired of overtime surprises?

Get control with Timeero's accurate tracking & insights.
Start a free trial today

Learn More

Need more information on this topic?