Managing Caregivers You Never See: The Reality of Running a Home Health Workforce

The management problem nobody talks about

‍

Most owners of home health or caregiving agencies begin with the desire to provide the best possible care for their patients. While this motivation is both sincere and heartfelt, business owners soon find out there is more to running a successful caregiving business than delivering exceptional patient care. 

‍

As the employer, you are responsible for how your team shows up in the field. Hiring the right staff and holding them accountable for their performance can become a problem very quickly if you are not prepared.  

‍

When a caregiver walks into the home of a patient, they represent your agency. For most healthcare businesses, there is no system in place to gather real-time job insights about employees. Without location visibility, how do you know they are showing up on time, or at all? 

‍

There’s a prevailing assumption that having real-time visibility in the field is a form of micromanagement, but that isn’t what this is at all. Being able to see the location of your caregivers helps you enforce the standards you’ve set for your business and uphold the level of service you’ve promised to your clients. 

Why home health is different from every other workforce management challenge

‍

There’s real liability in running a home care business. 

‍

Caregivers are hired to perform medically necessary tasks for patients. If a worker fails to show up to a patient’s site - either late, or misses the appointment entirely, there could be life threatening repercussions. If this happens, who does the blame fall on? Your agency.

‍

Unlike retail stores, restaurants or office environments where you can set up cameras to see what is happening on site, home health and caregiving businesses don’t have the ability to install physical equipment to allow real time visibility. 

The real cost of the visibility gap

For patients and families

‍

Without the details that real-time visibility provides, there’s no way to confirm a caregiver completed a visit or that medical tasks were performed, except by patient self-reporting. This method is unreliable, especially when patients suffer from mental and physical illnesses that may distort the details of what actually did or did not happen.

‍

Families and patients expect caregivers to deliver high quality patient care, as promised by the agency. If caregivers routinely show up late, or shorten their visit length, families and patients and quickly lose trust in your agency.

For the agency

‍

One of the costs an agency may incur is overpaying for unverified hours. 

‍

It’s common for workers to report they’ve worked more hours than they actually did. This happens when employees either estimate their total work hours, or intentionally pad hours to receive more pay. 

‍

When caregivers are paid for labor never performed, businesses risk Medicaid fraud and end up losing out on profit. 

‍

This is one of the reasons why the U.S. Congress mandated Electronic Visit Verification (EVV) for Medicaid funded home care businesses through the 21st Century Cures Act. 

For caregivers

‍

Employees generally want to work for a company with a solid organizational structure and processes in place. A company without visibility into daily activities signals to caregivers that the agency does not take their job seriously. 

‍

Good caregivers who consistently perform their jobs well, and show up to client visits on time want to be recognized for their hard work. Without a way for employers to see into the field, the work of good caregivers goes unnoticed.  

‍

When clients complain that their caregivers are not delivering medical care as needed, or aren’t showing up to their shifts on time, the lack of visibility provides no way for the caregiver to dispute the client’s claim.

‍

Caregivers who are actually doing what they were hired to do, don’t want to spend time proving they do the work. These caregivers usually end up leaving to work for another agency with real-time visibility tools. 

Why ‘just trust your caregivers’ isn’t a management strategy

‍

Trust is important and necessary for any organization to function.

‍

Going back to Vanessa’s quote, “you trust until you can’t anymore”, as a business owner,  I could sense the frustration, disappointment, and loss of trust she had in her caregivers. Unfortunately, she wasn’t in a position to terminate the caregivers who had committed fraud. Instead it sounded like she wasn’t going to trust them anymore.

‍

Of course, I am not proposing that business should foster a low trust environment. However, it’s important for businesses to take a trust but verify approach. I believe this is the path Vanessa took when she chose to use our services.

‍

Too often, we see business owners abdicating the verification portion because it may convey a lack of trust within their organizations. This couldn’t be further from the truth. Trust without verification isn’t management, it’s hope, and hope won’t get your business very far. 

‍

For example, you wouldn’t want to be treated at a hospital that was skimping over the important details. What if the nurses didn’t keep medication logs simply because they trust their staff to do the right thing? What if the doctors and nurses didn’t have a schedule because the hospital administrators simply trusted everyone to show up? 

‍

Somewhere down the line a nurse will probably forget to administer medication, and a doctor will show up late to a shift. By that time, patients have lost trust in the facility, and your business has lost a customer.

‍

 A good process and documentation protects everyone. Having a system in place that prevents missed appointments, late arrivals, and scales as your business grows past 20 caregivers is the key to building trust with your caregivers and patients. After all, most issues with caregivers don’t stem from ill intent or maliciousness. They are a result of forgetfulness, poor time management and unclear expectations. 

How technology bridges the visibility gap

‍

I’ve always believed one of the best ways to build a business is through transparency. Transparency doesn’t mean divulging all of your business plans or sensitive internal information. Being transparent means helping your team understand the what, where, why, and when of situations that occur in the workplace.

‍

Your clients and employees want transparency and visibility. This is why we built Timeero. 

‍

We once had a customer, the daughter of a home health patient, use Timeero to ensure the caregiver was showing up to her mom’s house in Phoenix, Arizona. She wanted to know when the caregiver arrived at her mother’s home, when she was leaving to run an errand, and when she left for the day. 

‍

Just like how Uber and DoorDash show the real-time locations of their drivers to create transparency and visibility for their users, with Timeero, home health agency owners can provide patients with transparency into caregivers’ activities like they have never had before.

Geofencing

‍

With geofencing and GPS verification technology, caregivers can only clock in when they are actually at the client or patient’s address. This way you can ensure they accurately account for hours worked at the patient’s home and not padding hours they never actually worked.

Automatic mileage tracking

‍

When caregivers make multiple patient visits each day, they rarely have time to stop and write down their mileage. Timeero automatically tracks mileage as soon as the caregiver starts the timeclock on their mobile app. This means no more piecing together drives at the end of the day.

Auto Clock-in/Out

‍

For caregivers who often forget to track their time, Timeero can automatically clock them in when they arrive at the client address. They can also be automatically clocked out when they leave the client’s location. This is a hands-free way to automatically record their visits, making time tracking one less thing your caregivers need to manage. 

Real-time visibility

‍

With Timeero you can see which caregivers are on site, who is late, and who hasn’t arrived for their shifts yet. These are all crucial accountability questions that need to be answered for any home care business, they are also the questions that clients want answers to.

EVV compliance

‍

Meeting EVV requirements can be challenging. Timeero can help you stay compliant with EVV requirements, capturing the data Medicaid needs to verify visits. Home care companies can also use Timeero to export time records that feed directly into state systems and payroll software, for accurate reporting. 

Overtime laws

‍

In addition to EVV compliance, your state may have laws in place regarding overtime. Timeero simplifies labor law compliance by allowing companies to customize overtime rules directly within the app. Employees and managers are notified when the overtime threshold is approaching, helping the company prevent FLSA violations.

How to introduce tracking to your caregivers without damaging trust

‍

‍

Introducing a workforce and location tracking software like Timeero doesn’t have to be a daunting task. Neither should it feel like its presence will damage employee trust. 

‍

Below are a few tips we’ve discovered over the years that can be tremendously helpful in getting your team to embrace a workforce tracking tool.

1. Be transparent 

‍

First, be transparent about the intentions of introducing a workforce visibility software. Explain to your team what is tracked and why it is being tracked. One of our biggest findings from our 2026 GPS Tracking & Employee Trust Survey Report, is that employees want to know when they are being tracked. 

‍

Explaining the why behind your decisions will help ease employee pushback when introducing new technology. Your team is more likely to get onboard when they understand the benefits to the company as a whole.

2. Reframe GPS as a form of protection

‍

Help your team understand that GPS tracking is a form of protection for caregivers, not a method of surveillance. If a client ever disputes that a caregiver was on site, a GPS app can provide time-stamped and location verified records to quickly resolve the dispute. 

3. Explain how GPS-verified timesheets equal accurate paychecks

‍

When your team uses a GPS app to track time and mileage, payroll errors are significantly reduced. This means your employees will receive accurate and on-time paychecks compensating them for their time and mileage traveled. 

4. Confirm when GPS tracking takes place - No after-hours tracking

‍

Many caregivers may voice privacy concerns around using a GPS tracking app. Helping your team understand what is being tracked, when it is being tracked, and why it is being tracked will help alleviate any concerns they may have about using a GPS app. Be sure to explain to your team during onboarding, and in your GPS tracking policy, that tracking only takes place during work hours. 

5. Develop a rollout approach

‍

How you introduce GPS tracking to your teams plays a part in their acceptance of the technology. Gather a small group of caregivers to test out the app before you introduce it to your whole workforce. Review individual feedback and determine if the app is the right fit for your business.

How automated GPS time tracking for home health agencies helps employers stay compliant

‍

‍

‍

As mentioned previously, home health care agencies encounter risks that other industries do not. For Medicaid funded agencies, having a way to prove patient visits took place in accordance with EVV requirements is extremely important. 

‍

Using an automated GPS time tracking system like Timeero can help home health companies stay compliant with EVV requirements. 

‍

As soon as a caregiver opens Timeero on their mobile device, they are asked to select a job at clock in. As soon as they hit “Start” their GPS location is captured, along with start time, job/patient name, and the date of visit. When they select “Stop” to end the visit, the GPS location is captured again, along with the end time. 

‍

Timeero’s EVV System captures all of the data points you need to deliver high-quality, compliant, patient care.

Your patients deserve to be seen — and so does the work your caregivers do

‍

It’s impossible for your home care agency to monitor the whereabouts of every caregiver, especially if you manage a large team. Using a workforce management app with real-time visibility can help you spot problems in caregiving before they become patient complaints. 

‍

Timeero gives you the real-time visibility, EVV compliance, and accurate timekeeping your agency needs to operate with confidence, protect your caregivers, and put patient care first. Start your free 14-day trial today.

FAQs

How do I verify that a caregiver actually visited a patient without being there myself?

‍

Timeero gives managers real-time visibility into field operations. Through the app’s “Who’s Working” dashboard, managers can see the current location of caregivers, including which patient they are currently with. When reviewing timecards, managers can also see the job/patient that caregivers clocked in and out of, along with the address and GPS location.

Is GPS tracking of caregivers legal?

‍

Yes. Tracking caregivers is legal. However, be sure you obtain their consent before introducing a GPS tracking app.

What's the best way to introduce time tracking to caregivers who are resistant?

‍

Being transparent is the best way to introduce GPS time tracking to your caregivers. Be clear during onboarding, and explain what data is being tracked, how it is being used, and when they are being tracked. The more details you provide, the more likely they are to accept GPS tracking.

Can Timeero track mileage between patient visits automatically?

‍

Yes. Timeero tracks mileage automatically as long as the employer is clocked into a job. 

How does accurate time tracking protect my agency during a Medicaid audit?

‍

GPS-verified time records show the exact times your caregivers were onsite delivering patient care. This protects your agency during a Medicaid audit, as the records show that you are submitting claims for time that was actually worked.

‍